Skip to main content

Shrink Happens.

How To Reduce Retail Theft This Holiday Season

The Holiday Rush Comes with Hidden Risks

For most retailers, the holiday season means longer hours, bigger crowds, and higher sales. But behind the glow of twinkling lights and ringing registers lurks a darker trend — a dramatic increase in retail theft.

According to the National Retail Federation (NRF), U.S. retailers lost $112.1 billion to shrink in 2022, up nearly 20% from the year before. Over 65% of that loss came from external theft, including shoplifting and organized retail crime (ORC). Meanwhile, 80% of retailers surveyed said violence associated with retail crime has increased over the past five years.

Theft isn’t just a criminal issue — it’s a business continuity issue. When losses mount, margins shrink, insurance costs rise, and employees feel unsafe. And during the holidays — when store traffic spikes 30–50% — every vulnerability becomes an open invitation.

At Guardian Alarm, we’ve protected local and national retailers for over 90 years. Our team of security experts has seen firsthand how evolving threats require evolving protection. In this article, we’ll explore why shrink happens, what today’s retailers can do about it, and how to build a prevention strategy that pays for itself.

Understanding the True Cost of Shrink

“Shrink” is the retail industry’s word for disappearing profits — the difference between recorded inventory and what’s actually on the shelf.

The NRF’s 2023 Retail Security Survey found:

  • Average shrink rate: 1.6% of total sales — roughly $700,000 lost per $1 billion in revenue.
  • Organized retail crime (ORC): Up 26% year-over-year.
  • Most targeted items: Apparel, electronics, health and beauty products, and liquor.

While those numbers may sound small, the ripple effect is massive. For a chain with $100 million in annual revenue, a 1.6% shrink rate equals $1.6 million in lost profit — enough to fund dozens of full-time employees, new technology, or an entire regional marketing campaign.

And the financial impact is just one layer. Shrink also affects:

  • Employee morale: Repeated incidents create stress and burnout.
  • Customer experience: Locked displays and long lines drive shoppers away.
  • Insurance premiums: Carriers increasingly tie rates to verified security systems.
  • Brand reputation: Viral videos of in-store chaos can tarnish a trusted brand overnight.

Retail theft doesn’t just “happen.” It adapts — just like your business should.

The New Face of Retail Theft

The modern shoplifter isn’t always a lone opportunist. In many cases, it’s part of a coordinated network.

Organized Retail Crime (ORC)

These groups target high-value goods that can be quickly resold online. According to Homeland Security Investigations, ORC has evolved into a $69 billion criminal enterprise, often crossing state lines. Retailers from Michigan to Ohio and beyond report surges in “smash-and-grab” events that take mere minutes.

Internal Theft

Employee theft accounts for nearly 30% of total retail losses, according to the NRF. Whether it’s inventory padding, fraudulent returns, or point-of-sale manipulation, weak internal controls invite risk.

Digital Fraud & Return Abuse

As retailers offer omnichannel shopping and easy returns, fraudsters exploit new vulnerabilities — swapping items, using fake receipts, or leveraging online return loopholes.

After-Hours Incidents

Vacant storefronts and warehouse facilities are prime targets during overnight hours or holiday closures.

The takeaway: Theft now moves faster, smarter, and often under the radar of traditional security systems.

The Guardian Framework: Deter, Detect, Document

At Guardian Alarm, our approach to business protection follows a proven framework — Deter. Detect. Document.
It’s not just a slogan — it’s how we turn security into strategy.

DETER

The best theft is the one that never happens.

  • Environmental Design: Bright lighting, clear camera visibility, and signage that announces surveillance make would-be thieves think twice.
  • Access Control: Limit entry to stockrooms, cash offices, and break areas. With Guardian’s integrated access control, credentials can be activated or deactivated instantly — perfect for managing seasonal staff.
  • Visible Presence: Studies show visible cameras can reduce theft incidents by up to 30%.
DETECT

Real-time insights prevent real losses.

  • Video Analytics: Guardian’s intelligent video systems use AI to identify loitering, crowd surges, and suspicious movement.
  • Remote Video Monitoring: Instead of reacting after the fact, Guardian’s 24/7 UL-Certified monitoring team intervenes during the event — alerting law enforcement before damage is done.
  • Multi-Site Dashboards: For regional or national chains, our business clients rely on mobile dashboards that give them visibility across every location — even from their phone.
DOCUMENT

Accountability drives improvement.

  • Cloud-Based Storage: Securely store evidence for law enforcement or insurance claims.
  • Incident Logs: Track what happened, who was on duty, and what corrective actions followed.
  • Analytics Reporting: Use incident data to refine staffing, layout, and policy decisions.

In other words — we don’t just catch theft; we prevent patterns.

Security as a Business Strategy

Loss prevention is no longer just about catching bad actors — it’s about protecting operations, profitability, and people.

Operational Efficiency

Retailers who adopt proactive monitoring and analytics often see 20–30% reductions in annual shrink. Fewer losses mean healthier margins and reinvestment opportunities.

Insurance Incentives

Carriers often reward verified alarm systems, UL-certified monitoring, and compliant access control with premium reductions of up to 15%.

Employee Retention & Safety

A 2024 NRF report found that 80% of retailers are concerned about rising aggression and violence in stores. Investing in security systems — panic buttons, access control, and visible monitoring — signals to employees that their safety matters.

Brand Experience

Locked displays and security guards used to be deterrents. Today, smart security blends seamlessly with customer experience.
Guardian’s discreet camera systems, mobile entry badges, and video-verified alarms protect without intruding — giving shoppers confidence that they’re in a safe, well-run store.

Your Holiday Theft Prevention Checklist

As you prepare for the busiest season of the year, use this Guardian-approved checklist to secure your stores and staff.

Before the Season Starts

  • Conduct a camera and alarm audit — ensure all systems are active and positioned correctly.
  • Review employee credentials and disable expired access.
  • Train staff on theft awareness and emergency protocols.
  • Communicate policies clearly — especially to new seasonal hires.

During Peak Shopping Hours

  • Position team members strategically for visibility and coverage.
  • Use video analytics to monitor queue lengths and congestion zones.
  • Keep displays tidy and well-lit — disorganization hides theft.
  • Maintain a consistent security presence near high-value areas.

After Hours

  • Activate alarm schedules with remote arming verification.
  • Confirm motion sensors and glass-break detectors are operational.
  • Use Guardian’s Remote Video Monitoring to maintain eyes on your property 24/7.

Post-Season Review

  • Analyze incident reports and patterns.
  • Recalculate shrink rates to measure ROI on prevention.
  • Plan upgrades for next year’s peak season.

Every measure you take now saves margin later.

The Future of Retail Security: Data-Driven Prevention

The future isn’t just cameras — it’s intelligence.
Video analytics can now:

  • Detect loitering in real time.
  • Map heat zones where theft risk is highest.
  • Correlate customer movement with sales data.

According to Allied Market Research, the global video analytics market is projected to reach $21.5 billion by 2030, growing at over 22% annually. Retailers adopting these tools early gain an edge — not just in safety, but in understanding customer behavior.

At Guardian Alarm, we integrate security with business intelligence, helping clients transition from reactive loss prevention to predictive risk management. Our technology doesn’t just keep you safe — it helps you run smarter stores.

Why Guardian Alarm

Guardian Alarm has protected Midwest businesses for more than nine decades. From Detroit to Toledo, Cleveland to Cincinnati, and beyond, we secure over 1 million people every day.

What makes us different?

  • Local Expertise: 24/7 UL-Certified monitoring right here in the Midwest.
  • Integrated Systems: Burglar, fire, video, and access control — all in one dashboard.
  • Trusted Partnerships: We help retailers of all sizes, from national chains to family-owned shops, build resilient operations that scale.

Whether you’re a single-location store or a regional brand, Guardian Alarm delivers protection that grows with your business.

Final Thoughts

Shrink may happen — but it doesn’t have to.
With the right mix of technology, training, and trusted expertise, your business can thrive through the holiday season and beyond.

At Guardian Alarm, we don’t just react to crime — we predict, prevent, and protect. This holiday season, stay focused on your customers while we focus on your safety.

Schedule Your Free Perimeter Survey Today

Guardian Alarm experts will walk your site, identify vulnerabilities, and design a layered protection plan to keep every corner covered.

Call 1.800.STAYOUT or visit GuardianAlarm.com/business-security to book your Free Perimeter Security Survey.

Free Quote